(This is an essay I recently wrote for school, hope you enjoy it and tell me your thoughts)
In the last few years questions about this issue have popped up again and again:
Is death penalty really something we need? Is it ok for the state to kill people, even if they have done horrible things? Do a judge and his jury have a right to decide upon life and death? The opinions are different and mostly opposite. A majority is against death penalty, while there are a few who endorse this idea of punishment.
One fact that these people give is the deterrent effect of this kind of punishment. But it is not convincing, because it is not proven that it really has a daunting effect on people that want to commit a crime. Because really- what kind of person that is ready to murder, that is ready TO BE a murderer, will stop just because there is a law of death penalty? When people are ready to do such horrible things, it is clear that they have broken through several borders in their head and it is very doubtful that fear is going to stop them, even the fear of getting caught and being sentenced to death. The fact that the number of people being killed in states with death penalty is even higher compared to other states without death penalty just shows how wrong this is. You can't prevent crime with death penalty.
The question of revenge is one of the most discussed ones in the death penalty issue. If your child or your husband or your mother or just anyone that stands close to you will get killed- wouldn't you want revenge? While most people would answer positive immeadiately, even without thinking for a second, there are still a few- even if they are very rare to find- that are going to say no. No to death penalty. Some of them because of naivety, because they haven't been confronted with this situation in real life. The others that ill say no to death penalty are what regular people would call 'today's saints'. People who say death penalty is inconsisent with human nature- and they mean it.
And that brings me to my next point: Is death penalty, or in this case lets call it killing on purpose, really inconsistent with human conscience? I would say NO! But still people do it, just the ones that get sentenced with death penalty themselves . So why not giving them what they deserve?- just what they did. Killing.
Though this might sound correct it is probably not. Because the murderer- who is that? Often it is a sick person, a desperate person or just someone who never knew anything different but crime, when all of your life you have been surrounded by crime you almost don't even have a chance to act differently. And who is the murderer in the case of death penalty? It's the state. A state has to be an example for the people that live in it. And what is this exact example that they are giving? That it is ok to kill? Because that is what their actions signalize. People don't see the state saying:
'Don't commit crime, you might get judged with death penalty!', they see a state that teaches that it is ok to kill, because it practices just the same.
Me, I was also a longtime supporter of death penalty. Of course only in cases where it seemed deserved. Until I realized that every coin has it's two sides, I realized that I didn't look too closely at ALL the facts surrounding the issue of death penalty and now I have to admit I'm against death penalty. NOT because I don't think some people don't deserve it, but because I feel that no one in this world should have LEGALLY the right to decide between death and life of a person, not even the highest court, whatsoever, you could find on the globe.
Yes, we have laws. Laws to protect us, laws to work out a good regular living, but we shouldn't have laws to kill us.
I personally like the idea of freedom and peace all over the world, still I do understand that this is an illusion and that it just doesn't lie in the human nature to be happy and to be peaceful. Therefore exist wars, crime and criminals. Unfortunately it will always be part of this world.
And death penaltyn won't prevent it. I'm sure.